Skip to main content

Unearthly Hour

At the Wall Street Journal, my friend who's just had a stint at this Mecca of journalism, says every story is edited and edited rigorously even if the story comes from a top editor. Simple logic: a story even if it is re-written for the nth time will still show flaws when seen by another pair of fresh eyes. Not a reflection on the writer's skills but speaks a lot about the practice at WSJ. And that’s the truth about writing -- there is always room and more room for improvement and collective thinking. So that's the journal for you, the benchmark of the highest practice in journalism today because of its writers and the desk, both of whom work in unison to create the brand it is.

Reporters in India are a set of personalities. Uptight, rigid and conventional about changes to their copies. Pointing changes is something they cannot wallow in their stride. The result: loose ends in sentences, jargon, overly flowery language -- are all passed in the name of 'writer's voice'. Bad stereotyping, but of late, my experiences have been pretty up the drawn. If every journalist was a born writer, desk hands would be redundant. There would have been just bellboys and reporters in the newsroom then.

Seasoned writers develop their own voice but that voice, too, comes with aid, lets not forget. Reporters would think otherwise. So, let’s call this professional discrimination. The discrimination is deep seated in many places. And that is the reason why we cannot do a WSJ much as we want to, because the standards set are by the ones who do not deviate from the average.

The bright side: the news business is getting more and more exciting in India than it was a decade ago. There is the flourish of all kinds of media outlet. There are people from all backgrounds and that gives the profession its colour and gossip. Some raw ones enter the profession with the clich├ęs “to contribute to society” and what not! Boy did I not too start with the same fervour? Soon it all boiled down to chasing deadlines, while service to society went for a toss. And oh the byline craze? Till death do us part, that craze is here to stay. That applies to all rungs in the hierarchy. Megalomania. Bingo!

It’s 3:30 am. I am waiting for my story. And I am a pretty disillusioned soul just now!


Snigdha said…
the desk at wsj is very very good. you simply cant leave rewriting to the desk here, india, because, sub editors are as bad at writing, editing and thinking as reporters are. i agree that reporters are megalomaniacs and most of them would not get a job in a decent newspaper or magazine elsewhere in the world. but exactly the same also holds true for desk hands. and things wont improve till people stop playing the blame game. we all suck. the sooner we see that, the better for all of us. but then journos are rarely sensible people.
annie said…
Interesting read!!
Snigdha said…
hey indie, long time no post. all fine?
Anonymous said…
Fantastic site, I had not noticed earlier during my searches!
Carry on the excellent work!
Anonymous said…
I give birth to infer from a insufficient of the articles on your website trendy, and I really like your fashionableness of blogging. I added it to my favorites web age list and resolve be checking stand behind soon. Please check out my put as approvingly and fail me be acquainted with what you think. Thanks.

Popular posts from this blog

A Mad Man Or A Boor

What does one do when one encounters a mad dog? Or what does one do when one encounters a man with pre-fixed notions about everything in life, most specifically of women who live alone and give him some importance? The two are equivalent to me and basic intelligence says avoid the paths they tread like plague. But I chose to tackle them head on. I almost got rabbies. The mad man said [sic] " You sound like a very desperate person. A single and frustrated woman who is looking for anyone to leave a comment on your blog so much so that you wouldn't even spare a spammer ." Spammer being, the first comment on the previous post is apparently a spam, an advert for T-shirts. Bummer! I thought it was a handsome Spaniard or Latino, so I had replied "Hi Rodrigo", hoping to take the conversation forward offline. Anyway! All this the mad man found out. I didnt. Sure, I dig comments because I love the spontaneity and intelligence of my friends. And I didn't invite the ma


Two million people at the National Mall in Washington alone. The world watched too as Barack Obama was sworn in as the 44th President of the United States. So did I. I rudely cut roomie's soap operas and switched to CNN to witness history being created. Some day I may live to tell the tale of how Barack, the much touted Afro-American President of the United States, stumbled with his swearing-in oath. I was a bit disappointed as I watched the man who had run the most successful of election campaigns, the man who Americans were pinning their hopes on, take his oath. Clearly, he was under too much of a pressure to be the best. So before Chief Justice John Roberts could complete the first sentence, there was Obama abruptly breaking out into his first names... " I Barack Hussein Obama.." and then waited for the judge to complete the sentence.. The next line was even taxing. He stopped short after two words... " That I will excute ..." and then Justice Roberts cont

Good Girls Don't Drink?

I have been disturbed by the news coming out of my region – the northeast of India - where a teenage girl coming out of a bar at 9:30 pm was molested and beaten by a group of 20 men. The news has even found its way down under for the shocking nature of it. Tabloids and even TV have carried the news. I have always prided myself in belonging to a region that is known for its high tolerance and where women are generally safe and independent. But I have always felt a bit squidgy about Guwahati unlike the rest of the seven sisters. The place is so like the rest of India in many ways, dirty and claustrophobic. That explains why bars are looked upon as sleazy places and women going there beaten up as with the recent case. Just 150 km away is Shillong, the place where I grew up. Night clubs thrive there and till date there has been no case of attacks against women. Reading the news, I am appalled by some of the reactions. “But the girl was drinking,” or “only prostitutes visit that