Skip to main content

Open Ended

It’s funny sometimes how the logic of an argument gets tilted by one’s pre-conceived notions about things. Because this is what I would exactly term the following. I was reading an article on Time magazine about how Haji Bashai Noorzai, an Afghan warlord or druglord as he has been variously described, got into these ‘deal’ with American agencies about how he could be of value to America’s fight against terrorism by trading information for freedom and 'no capture’. But on reaching Manhattan, Noorzai does his job and when he is about to leave, he is arrested instead. Deal over, trust broken.

Now, I am not debating the intricacy of it all, not debating Noorzai’s credentials or the US’s stance in arresting him. But my first reaction as a citizen of the world is: why backtrack on a deal and stab someone from behind? That to me is heinous a crime as anything else. It’s just unacceptable that you enter into a contract of ‘give and take’ with someone and without warning, the other party sidesteps and arm-twists the deal to their advantage and pin the other party down. And what would happen to all the principles and ethics of the world if we were to say that just because one is a thief, a deal with him shouldn’t be respected? Why enter the deal in the first place, then?

That is my ire. But my British colleague goes off in a tangent and counter questions me. He says the likes of Noorzai are responsible for thousands of deaths and for the flourish of illegal opium trade in the world. And so, would I support him knowing that and let him off? Surely, no. Coming from an insurgency ridden place, I know more about terrorism and about living with terrorism than him. I do not condone terrorism, I hate it all as much I loath the Islamic world for their parochial view about things. And maybe the likes of Noorzai, again, are abetting terrorism in Kashmir, he goes on. Probably, presumably. But that is not my point again. My point is: Noorzai as a human had a right for his deal to be honoured, so that is why we have criminals/terrorists turning approvers too. It doesn’t help the argument, he replies because the bottom line is terrorists are terrorists.

Dragged into what is turning out to be a 'for' and 'against' Noorzai debate, much against my intention, I go on: “Then, would it help if Noorzai remained in his home country and carried on with his heinous crimes killing more people in the long run, than for him to have turned informant and help the US fight terrorism? Isn’t it good for society in general that he leave his past and take sides with people who are on the right side of law? Isn’t the deal good then, shouldn't the deal have been mutually respected then…” My young Brit friend answers: "How do you know he will not go back to his old trade?"

I have run out of steam, my argument defies a white man's logic.


Anonymous said…
i guess your friend has not heard of the saying that u dont kill the goose laying golden eggs. This one act of betrayal will stop many from giving inside info of various mafia operations.
Shanti Thokchom said…
Definitely this act of betrayal would not make anyone to come forward to help.
Anonymous said…
All's fair in love and war

Popular posts from this blog

A Mad Man Or A Boor

What does one do when one encounters a mad dog? Or what does one do when one encounters a man with pre-fixed notions about everything in life, most specifically of women who live alone and give him some importance? The two are equivalent to me and basic intelligence says avoid the paths they tread like plague. But I chose to tackle them head on. I almost got rabbies.

The mad man said [sic] "You sound like a very desperate person. A single and frustrated woman who is looking for anyone to leave a comment on your blog so much so that you wouldn't even spare a spammer." Spammer being, the first comment on the previous post is apparently a spam, an advert for T-shirts. Bummer! I thought it was a handsome Spaniard or Latino, so I had replied "Hi Rodrigo", hoping to take the conversation forward offline. Anyway! All this the mad man found out. I didnt. Sure, I dig comments because I love the spontaneity and intelligence of my friends. And I didn't invite the mad m…

Glam Gurumaa

Have you ever met a so called godwoman or godman in person? Well I did and I have to talk about this one. On Tuesday night, I got a call asking if I would like to come and meet Anandmurti Gurumaa. My knowledge about ‘spiritual people’ as they would like to call themselves is zero because I have never taken interest in their ilk and India being full of conmen in the garb of spiritualists you tend to look at them with suspicion. I had a friend who stayed for weeks at a house cramped with people in a shady lane in Delhi and they were all fighting and scrambling for the baba’s attention. The baba would perform pujas during the evenings, make them drink and wash with ashes and they would pour heaps of money buying the essentials. The people went to him for all reasons – to sort marital discords, business failures, illnesses, and even vengeance on enemies! It was frightful. I had gone to meet the friend but after a few hours scooted away more scared I would pick a bug from the unhygienic su…

Them Versus Us

Taking off from the Shilpa 'Shitty' issue (I love the surname and that comes from my ever so humorous and intellectual friend Latha or Lotty with love and Angel No. 1 to some :)), here are some reflections on being a north easterner in the capital of the world's largest democracy. Also, Lotty, on a serious note, says I should have a NE angle to what I write. She has a point. I have enough material there, enough to give vent to.

I begin with 'oye Chinky'. When I came to Delhi in the mid 1990s to do a professional course, I wasn't sure what the word meant. Maybe I was too busy paying heed to my new found independence and the certain sense of security -- the fact that I could go to the market even at 10 pm without the peering eyes of the army or the CRPF personnel patrolling the streets and stiffling our existence. It wasn't until my course was over and I got myself a break as a sub editor with the country's premier news agency, that I had my first hand exp…